Reply
Thread Tools
Posts: 339 | Thanked: 1,623 times | Joined on Oct 2013 @ France
#1
Hello,

In these difficult times, I have seen a call to help funding the mer infrastructure (https://twitter.com/locusf/status/668409070643257344).

At the same time, I have seen a comment on a blog, stating that developing mer is redondant with what Yocto provides (Linux, Wayland, Qt, ...), but with Yocto supported by the linux foundation and industrial companies.

* I never thought of it that way, but indeed, what is the difference between Mer and Yocto ?
* What does Mer provides that Yocto doesn't ?
* Is that only a schedule consequence that Yocto didn't exist or was not as supported as it is now, when Mer was chosen/started ?
* Isn't it too late to rebase Sailfish OS on top of Yocto ? The hardware adaptation layer would need a lot of work propably for the Jolla, but the upper stack (Nemo, Silica and other sailfish OS packages) shouldn't need that much changes than writing new bitbake recipes, isn't it ?
* Would switching to Yocto make it faster to port it to future hardware, as a lot are supported now ? Maybe not as good support on multimedia models like Mediatek then industrial platforms like iMx6 and SAMA5 ?


Feel free to explain with technical details, I uses Yocto a bit at work, and tried porting Sailfish to xt897 using the HADK, so I should be able to follow (even if not being able to do it by myself...).

Thanks !
 

The Following 11 Users Say Thank You to Zeta For This Useful Post:
Posts: 602 | Thanked: 735 times | Joined on Mar 2011 @ Nantes, France
#2
I just read a bit about Yocto and it doesn't seem to be in contradiction with Mer. As far as I understood, Yocto is project to provide an ecosystem which can help to create Linux distributions for the embedded world, not a distribution in itself. And Yocto targets embedded Linux, but not only mobile phones.

Mer is a distribution which targets mobile phones.

I would say with Yocto you can create Mer...which already exists. Didn't really see the added value in this particular case, but I didn't too long to read about Yocto.
 

The Following 5 Users Say Thank You to romu For This Useful Post:
Posts: 307 | Thanked: 1,460 times | Joined on May 2011 @ Switzerland
#3
I got the same thing from that, though Mer is not built with Yocto, and it could be a bit more flexible if it could be and perhaps save some cash. I couldn't tell if Yocto was for maintaining distributions or just creating them though.
 

The Following 3 Users Say Thank You to billranton For This Useful Post:
Posts: 165 | Thanked: 625 times | Joined on Oct 2012
#4
IIRC, Linux Foundation was backing MeeGo (Which Mer continues), and is already backing Tizen. So, it seems that even Linux Foundation doesn't consider Yacto and Tizen/MeeGo the same product.
__________________
My N9 apps: MeeTeleGram, Dukto, Prayers, Saaghar, N9 Easy Boot
Donations are appreciated
 

The Following 3 Users Say Thank You to hedayat For This Useful Post:
wicket's Avatar
Posts: 634 | Thanked: 3,266 times | Joined on May 2010 @ Colombia
#5
I'm going to sound boring here as I've mentioned this many times before, but still, it's pertinent to this thread so I'll say it again.

One significant difference is that Mer uses outdated, unmaintained and possibly vulnerable GPLv2 packages to allow vendors to Tivoise their devices.

Yocto provides recent, maintained GPLv3 packages for those that care about security, but they also provide unmaintained GPLv2 packages for those vendors that prefer Tivoisation to security.
__________________
DebiaN900 - Native Debian on the N900. Deprecated in favour of Maemo Leste.

Maemo Leste for N950 and N9 (currently broken).
Devuan for N950 and N9.

Mobile devices with mainline Linux support - Help needed with documentation.

"Those who do not understand Unix are condemned to reinvent it, poorly." - Henry Spencer
 

The Following 10 Users Say Thank You to wicket For This Useful Post:
Posts: 339 | Thanked: 1,623 times | Joined on Oct 2013 @ France
#6
Originally Posted by hedayat View Post
IIRC, Linux Foundation was backing MeeGo (Which Mer continues), and is already backing Tizen. So, it seems that even Linux Foundation doesn't consider Yacto and Tizen/MeeGo the same product.
It has been so for Meego (there was Nokia and Intel backing it), but doesn't seem to have follow with Mer. There is no mention of it in the projects of the foundations (where you can see Yocto and Tizen) :
http://collabprojects.linuxfoundatio...ative-projects
 

The Following 2 Users Say Thank You to Zeta For This Useful Post:
Posts: 339 | Thanked: 1,623 times | Joined on Oct 2013 @ France
#7
Otherwise, no one know the differences that would make Mer more meaningful than Yocto for its use case, and thus worth funding ?
 
coderus's Avatar
Posts: 6,436 | Thanked: 12,699 times | Joined on Nov 2011 @ Ängelholm, Sweden
#8
Originally Posted by romu View Post
Mer is a distribution which targets mobile phones.
Stop posting ******** please
__________________
Telegram | Openrepos | GitHub | Revolut donations
 

The Following User Says Thank You to coderus For This Useful Post:
Posts: 165 | Thanked: 625 times | Joined on Oct 2012
#9
Originally Posted by Zeta View Post
It has been so for Meego (there was Nokia and Intel backing it), but doesn't seem to have follow with Mer. There is no mention of it in the projects of the foundations (where you can see Yocto and Tizen) :
http://collabprojects.linuxfoundatio...ative-projects
Yes, it doesn't back Mer & I didn't mean it. I said that it backed Meego & is backing Tizen. & Mer is the continuation of Meego.

If Yacto is an alternative to Mer, it is probably an alternative to Tizen too (or at least Tizen can be based on it).

P.S. Actually, I has been thinking if bringing Nemo & hardware adaptation based on Fedora is viable! If I had enough time, I'd try to see how hard is it! IMHO, it'd be better if Nemo was built on top of an active distribution, so that contributors can focus on mobile specific things rather than the whole distribution. But I should admit that I don't know how much Mer is different from a regular distribution.
__________________
My N9 apps: MeeTeleGram, Dukto, Prayers, Saaghar, N9 Easy Boot
Donations are appreciated

Last edited by hedayat; 2015-11-25 at 07:09.
 

The Following 5 Users Say Thank You to hedayat For This Useful Post:
Posts: 602 | Thanked: 735 times | Joined on Mar 2011 @ Nantes, France
#10
Originally Posted by coderus View Post
Stop posting ******** please
Could you please give some arguments?

Here, first line of the Mer web site:

Mer is an open, mobile-optimised, core distribution aimed at device manufacturers
 

The Following 2 Users Say Thank You to romu For This Useful Post:
Reply

Thread Tools

 
Forum Jump


All times are GMT. The time now is 10:08.