Reply
Thread Tools
Posts: 425 | Thanked: 132 times | Joined on Mar 2008 @ California
#1
I don't know what exactly to categorize this as, because it's not really a bug, more of an incompatibility. As some of you have probably realized, KDE on the tablet doesn't behave nicely with respect to screen rotation.

To show that I've done my homework, this problem is discussed in fairly isolated posts scattered throughout the forums; in Penguinbait's Clone OS to SD Deb!! thread, in the How to rotate screen on os2008 thread, in the KDE Installation Poll, and in the original KDE 3.5.6 Available thread posted by Penguinbait.

None of the above threads contain a long-term definitive answer, (although Benson did come pretty close here, more on that later). So I thought, well, I'll look into it and come up with my own answer . Easier said than done.

Myth #1: KDE's screen resolution doesn't change to 480x800
-Okay, so easy answer: just change the resolution beforehand using KrandrTray. However you have to add the resolution to either Xfree.conf or Xorg.conf or Xorg.config according to several Kubuntu forums I looked at, and the tablet version has none of these files, so only one resolution is available:

But this turns out to be a moot point anyway:
TRUTH #1: The resolution rotates just fine, but the window manager doesn't, as evidenced by the screenshot below:


Okay so Myth #2: KDE just plain doesn't support screen rotation.
TRUTH #2: Yes it does! Following Benson's suggestion (thanks man) I started up KDE with my screen already rotated, and it comes up beautifully:


This is all well and good, but when I slide out my keyboard, due to emjayes' sliderotate, KDE switches to the normal orientation as it's supposed to, but then when I close the keyboard, or switch back using the power key I get this familiar crap:


So my conclusion is that the KDE window manager/desktop app isn't being rotated back correctly. My suspicion is further confirmed by the fact that KDE displays the same behavior when rotated by KrandrTray or by the Desktop settings panel.

Why would this be though? I assume KDE can actually rotate the display correctly, (I can't check because my VirtualBox installation of Kubuntu won't let me access the rotation settings) So my current opinion is that it's just a bug(?) in the tablet KDE.

So now, is there any way to fix this? Any ideas? Sorry to bug you Penguinbait, but I'm really hoping you could take a look at this if it isn't too much to ask I really really appreciate the work you've put into KDE and I love my K810, but rotation support would make this the best handheld user interface I've ever used!

In particular, the hildon-apps menu looks MUCH better:


And this would really help with dialogs that extend too far in the vertical direction as KDE has no qualms about you dragging dialogs off the sides of the screen to your heart's content
Many thanks in advance
Josiah
__________________
Promises are like babies. Fun to make, but hard to deliver.

Warning: dates on calendar are closer than they appear.

Last edited by josiahg777; 2008-05-09 at 04:10. Reason: Fixed spelling. (Sorry Emjayes)
 

The Following 2 Users Say Thank You to josiahg777 For This Useful Post:
Benson's Avatar
Posts: 4,930 | Thanked: 2,272 times | Joined on Oct 2007
#2
If you can use ssh with x forwarding to run a "normal" (i.e. x86) KDE on your tablet's X server, you could see if that works; if so, it's pb's fault , and if not, then it seems to be an upstream KDE problem.

It's definitely a bug somewhere, if it rotates one way, but not the other...
 
Posts: 425 | Thanked: 132 times | Joined on Mar 2008 @ California
#3
Yeah... I'm hoping this thread will spark some ideas and/or motivate somebody to fix it. I'm a relative Linux noobie, so I'm hoping one of the tablet gods will look favorably on my humble request
__________________
Promises are like babies. Fun to make, but hard to deliver.

Warning: dates on calendar are closer than they appear.
 
Posts: 234 | Thanked: 40 times | Joined on Nov 2007 @ Cincinnati, Ohio USA
#4
I think the rotated view would be fine if you have your toolbar on the top or left side. As long as you can drag apps down to use the black space (like the keyboard). The first view seems to indicate that.

I've just started exploring KDE and nearly gave up since I couldn't find the keyboard. I know know it's there and will look again. In portrait mode I could leave the keyboard open.
 
Reply

Tags
kde, kde35


 
Forum Jump


All times are GMT. The time now is 15:29.