View Single Post
Benson's Avatar
Posts: 4,930 | Thanked: 2,272 times | Joined on Oct 2007
#11
Originally Posted by jmjanzen View Post
how about formally dividing the site into the tiers you're describing? and reward people for answering newbie questions by advancing them to a higher tier, where more difficult questions could be answered by the members who are tired of answering newb questions. newbies would not be allowed beyond the newbie tier until they've received thanks or something from $x newbies, then they'd be granted higher-level access and they could choose not to be bothered by newbie posts anymore. (and so on and so forth, with several, or at least a few, tiers total.)

surely this has been tried before...?
If it has, I'm sure it's failed miserably. Don't get me wrong, it's a very interesting notion, and possibly quite productive overall, but it would be really annoying to quick learners or ingrafts from other UNIX backgrounds. Or just people like me, who don't really do any kernel hacking, but would want the ability to drop in on the really interesting threads at that level. (Actually, I doubt any real kernel discussion takes place or is expected on Ubuntu forums, but the same attitude applies to other levels.)

And that sort of authoritarian slotting of people into classes rubs a huge number of people the wrong way, especially those actually involved in OSS; it might drastically prune the upper tiers, just from aversion to the concept, even though they would have been grandfathered in at an unrestricted level. On the other hand, one should never underestimate the power of the mind to rationalize authoritarianism for the sake of slotting ignorant, annoying, helpless imbeciles into their appropriate classes.