maemo.org - Talk

maemo.org - Talk (https://talk.maemo.org/index.php)
-   Neo900 (https://talk.maemo.org/forumdisplay.php?f=57)
-   -   Neo900 - finally a successor of N900 (https://talk.maemo.org/showthread.php?t=91142)

joerg_rw 2013-08-25 21:32

Neo900 - finally a successor of N900
 
so it begun:

Introducing the Neo900 project - the first true successor for N900


we (the Neo900 team) are currently in the planning phase about a maemo5/fremantle-compatible successor of N900, with N900 look-alike (aka case) and a processor with more grunt and RAM.

This is already beyond the state of vaporware, see www.gta04.org which this will base on.

I.E. the GTA04 exists (350+ working units sold), what we're talking about are slight modification to GTA04 board to make it fit into a
Neo900, with housing, display, digitizer aka touchpanel, cameras etc sourced from the commercial N900 spare parts market. (though our primary target is to provide ready-to-run complete devices, we will also offer an option for you to buy the GTA04-NeoNinehundred board only, instead of the complete Neo900 device, to upgrade any N900 you already may have)
So it wll look like a N900, feel like a N900 and work like a N900, just way faster, thanks to the DM3730 CPU @1GHz and at least 512MB RAM (1GB depending on chip availability) plus maybe a few GB more of fast RAM-based "storage" as swap.
And - that's our plan - it will have all the functionality you're used to from N900 plus sturdy USB (that won't fall off the PCB) with full OTG support, all sorts of new nice sensors like gyro and altimeter and compass, and at your choice a GSM/UMTS (3.5G) or LTE (4G) modem that doesn't break (or when it ever would then you can fix it).
The AV/headset connector will offer new stereo line-in function on top of the usual mono mic and stereo-out and video.
We will add a general purpose expansion interface under that battery lid - funny enough it turns out it's a superset of what Jolla is using on their TOH interface.

Plus the whole device is 100% open, you get all the schematics and links to all the datasheets of the 'free' chips that are used. *), we don't work behind walls.

The project is about the hardware, we can't run a software development department to port maemo to the device. It's up to a community effort to establish this. Two volunteers already hollered: freemangordon whom you all know from CSSU, and FatPhil, an ex_Nokia kernel maintainer :-) Many thanks to both! And I mustn't miss to mention that a lot of other community members also offered to help wherever they can in our newly formed fremantle porting task force. Many thanks to all of you too.

Stay tuned for more to come :-) Please note Dos1's excellent post#5 below!


*)
what we we possibly will hand out later on only are the Eagle project files to feed the fab with. We won't hand out the "shopping list" with all the commercial contacts. What's also not available are docs about the powervr graphics core, but device works without using that core. We don't have access to any modem firmware sourcecode or sources for other subsystem firmwares.


cheers
jOERG

PS: I added a public poll, to allow for evaluating if we might reach the minimum of 200 preorders with a target of 700EUR per complete device (just ballpark figures!)

Context Links:
http://www.mwkn.net/2013/36/front.html
https://blogs.fsfe.org/pboddie/?p=430
http://talk.maemo.org/showthread.php?t=91308
http://mobile.slashdot.org/comments....3&cid=44840495

some timeline: http://talk.maemo.org/showthread.php?p=1374716
disclaimer: this project is not related to or driven by the maemo community council, nor does it get any support from council or HiFo

Update:
FUNDRAISER succeeded, development started - see http://neo900.org
FOR SHIPPING DESTINATIONS PLEASE NOTE http://talk.maemo.org/showthread.php?p=1383775 and http://talk.maemo.org/showthread.php...99#post1407199

Update2[2014-06-17]:
Sorry for neglecting this post#1 for so long, we shouldn't have urged you into reading 1000s of posts in several threads to get latest status.
The project is now under responsibility of a company dedicated to Neo900 exclusively: the (surprising name :) ) Neo900 UG
We're still about to complete the process of transferring assets from GDC who originally held responsibility, to the new Neo900 UG - however that's basically irrelevant for our supporters since nothing really changes for you from this.
We started to accept donations again, after we had to suspend this for a while during the GDC->UG transfer, see http://neo900.org/#donate . This is still low profile since we need to sort out our "fineprint" to be in line with the way we promised to handle your donations, but we're about to improve this during the next few weeks.
On the technical side we are about to build our 3rd version of prototype boards with a lot of exciting stuff that's unique and new with Neo900, compared to both of its ancestors N900 and GTA04 (well, the latter obviously has more already of the sensors and stuff we plan to cram on protoV3) - we're just on hold until the majority of our donors transferred their donation from GDC to UG, so the UG can actually order the proto hardware to get built. So if you donated and haven't taken care to add an according note to your GDC order management page already, please do that now. Thanks for your support and patience to all our donors. The V3 will demonstrate working display, working modem incl the more relevant part of our security concept to monitor the modem, working charging and possibly battery hotswap incl improved charger detection independant of CPU support.
Finally I missed to officially introduce Werner Almesberger here. We're very glad to welcome him on board of the Neo900 core developer team.

Please stay tuned for us doing a major overhaul of our website http://neo900.org to represent more in realtime all the progress we made so far. We're going to get a microblog there really soon now, to keep you up to date with what's going on.

Update3[2014-06-23]
microblog added to website
donation now open again, even via PayPal. Stay tuned, bitcoins may be around the corner. ;)
Hoping to continue with ProtoV2 (in some locations called V3 since it's 3rd PCB) next week.
Please all donors (those wo already donated) check your GDC order page if not done already. Aso see http://neo900.org/donate-gdc

peterleinchen 2013-08-25 21:36

Re: Neo900 - finally a successor of N900
 
Wahoo! :D

Fremantle-compatible means?

joerg_rw 2013-08-25 21:38

Re: Neo900 - finally a successor of N900
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by peterleinchen (Post 1369344)
Wahoo! :D

Fremantle-compatible means?

to be discussed. It means same apps, same user experience, same knowledge base.
My idea is to make it possible to run fremantle apps on the Neo900, dialer and all other stock apps as well as everything straight from maemo-extras repo. We'll see how that pans out. Worst case we need a custom built rootfs and dedicated Neo-repositories. We need developers who help to port fremantle kernel and core system to the new platform (which is also an OMAP3, so it should be feasible). Ideally the new platform will be so much identical to N900 that you simply can flash PR1.3 to it and it just works. There are a few minor obstacles that forbid this ideal: Nolo and modem. I think both is manageable.

n900hacker 2013-08-25 21:45

Re: Neo900 - finally a successor of N900
 
Yeah! I fully support this idea!

dos1 2013-08-25 21:54

Re: Neo900 - finally a successor of N900
 
Hello, I'm Sebastian Krzyszkowiak (dos), member of Openmoko community and strong supporter of GTA04. And now also Neo900 :)

First, a bit of back-story:
GTA04 was designed as a drop-in replacement for Neo1973/Neo Freerunner (from Openmoko project) motherboards. It comes from Open Phoenux initiative created by Golden Delicious, one of former Openmoko distributors. You know, apt-get upgrade for hardware ;) It's as open and free as you can get - only 3D acceleration needs binary blob, but everything works great even without it; there's also non-free WiFi firmware. But other than that - it's 100% free, you can control everything that runs on main CPU, just like with previous Openmoko phones.

It already works, there are around ~100 GTA04's in Openmoko community. There are already few OSes available (QtMoko, SHR, Debian) and Replicant (Android) is in works.

But there are few problems with GTA04: there's no dedicated case for it. You have to use refurbished GTA01/02 ones, and they are rare (not in production anymore) and expensive. GTA04 itself is not cheapest too - that's due to low demand.

But... joerg_rw recently came up with amazing idea to modify GTA04 board, upgrade some components etc. and use N900 cases instead of Openmoko ones. Second source N900 housings are easily and cheaply available on eBay, and hw-keyboard form factor will surely appeal more people.

What's more - part of joerg_rw's idea is to port Fremantle. As it it now - providing full compatibility. That would make GTA04-N900 vel. Neo900 a drop-in replacement for current N900 users. The same software, the same repos, the same everything - just faster, better and supported!

(level of backwards compatibility is still to be discussed - maybe removing some proprietary Maemo cruft will do better for us? Or maybe providing full, 100% compatibility will allow us to get more customers? Discuss! :) )

I think this is what both of our communities (Maemo and Openmoko) were waiting for so long - a proper successor for our phones. I'm all hyped for it!

Of course this is early planning stage, lots of things will probably change, but please please please, if you're interested - show it! We need to know how many people will want to buy one when it comes out. Low production runs are already pretty expensive, but if there are more people interested, it can get much cheaper.

Golden Delicious already showed with GTA04 that if there's demand, they can design and produce working, nice hardware. This is no vaporware of any kind, this is real project in its first days.

If you have any questions about both GTA04 or Neo900, feel free to ask :)

BTW. This is about current GTA04 prices depending on demand, just to give you all some insight:
Quote:

> 1 buyer: 3000 EUR
> 10 buyers: 1500 EUR
> 100 buyers: 590 EUR
> 1000 buyers: 490 EUR (here it would include a better CPU, e.g. OMAP4)
> 10k buyers: 390 EUR (here it would include a new plastic case)
> 100k buyers: 290 EUR
> 1 Mio buyers: 240 EUR
> 10 Mio buyers: 199 EUR
PS. Feel free to spread the word about Neo900! :)

MINKIN2 2013-08-25 21:57

Re: Neo900 - finally a successor of N900
 
Ummm, if they are making a chipset to fit a look-alike case... Could there be any chance of making the chipset fit an existing n900 shell?

Edit: Dumb post, my bad should have paid closer attention to first post.

dos1 2013-08-25 21:59

Re: Neo900 - finally a successor of N900
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by MINKIN2 (Post 1369349)
Ummm, if they are making a chipset to fit a look-alike case... Could there be any chance of making the chipset fit an existing n900 shell?

That's exactly the point of this project :) To adapt GTA04 to use N900 casing and screen instead of Openmoko ones.

MINKIN2 2013-08-25 22:03

Re: Neo900 - finally a successor of N900
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by dos1 (Post 1369350)
That's exactly the point of this project :) To adapt GTA04 to use N900 casing and screen instead of Openmoko ones.

Yup, just saw your post as I was refreshing my page. Sorry. :)

Really, If this takes off then the prices of those Broken USB n900s or are going to sky rocket! I have one waiting already for this project.

Estel 2013-08-25 22:04

Re: Neo900 - finally a successor of N900
 
1st april was a while ago.

Seriously though, yes, I would buy one in a heartbeat, even before all software whistles would get finished. Probably would do so, instead of buying Jolla ("probably" is about instead, not about "may buy or may not") ;)

Proposed price is quite rough (AIUI it is "only" a board, screen module, case, etc to be re-used), but I get that such niche (as compared to mass market) project can't get ready boards for cheap.
---

Still, consider that expectations would be quite high, i.e no hardware feature missing (including peripherials like FM receiver/transmitter, IR transmitter, etc), and real hope for having CSSU'ish Hildon as UI.

As for "could we replace closed source components where possible", I think that doing so would even increase number of buyers. We don't need 100% fremantle copy - it have it own flaws. We need100% fremantle features, prefferably without those flaws, and with more room to expand. So, the more FOSS in it, the better.

/Estel

dos1 2013-08-25 22:15

Re: Neo900 - finally a successor of N900
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Estel (Post 1369353)
1st april was a while ago :(

This is not a joke! :) I think it's the best way to combine potential of those two communities. Open Phoenux, coming from Openmoko, showed that it's possible to create and sell new, working device while staying true to FOSS spirit. Maemo community has great foundations for supporting software (Openmoko community rather failed in this regard - our OSes were amazing for hacking and playing, but not really for actual usage).

GTA04 works, Fremantle works. Both have rather poor demand at the moment, because both work separately - GTA04 without proper software and Fremantle without proper hardware. Let's combine it and do something that rocks! :)

lexik 2013-08-25 22:17

dreams, plans, future
 
Okey guys,

this project is probably the future of N900. And Maemo.
What is possible:
  • Full Android compatibility - the Replicant project, see www.replicant.us for more details. That means NO problems with wifi, bluetooth or camera as in NITDroid project.
  • Upstream kernel - 3.10, there are a few "issues" but it can be fixed. If we want the true Maemo successor, it's a bad idea to port it with old kernel.

...

And more. Its now just on you. With new HW, with new open hardware, we could make amazing things.

This, is the next step in evolution of Maemo.
What we are looking for now, are coders (kernel porting..), graphics (some propagation stuff - website, addvertisments and so on..) and, finally, you guess right, money.

Now we need just something about $200 - for an experimental n900 for openmoko community.

If you want to donate, you can do so via Donation to Hildon foundation. Or you can donate the whole (but functional) N900, if you want.

Feel free to augment this thread. We are Maemo :) Not Nokia.

#lexik

joerg_rw 2013-08-25 22:19

Re: Neo900 - finally a successor of N900
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by MINKIN2 (Post 1369352)
Yup, just saw your post as I was refreshing my page. Sorry. :)

Really, If this takes off then the prices of those Broken USB n900s or are going to sky rocket! I have one waiting already for this project.

Nope, unlike original GTA04 we plan to use new spare cases and spare parts for LCD.

lonk 2013-08-25 22:27

Re: Neo900 - finally a successor of N900
 
would it also use a resistive touchscreen like the n900?

joerg_rw 2013-08-25 22:29

Re: Neo900 - finally a successor of N900
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by lonk (Post 1369359)
would it also use a resistive touchscreen like the n900?

It will use original N900 touchscreen and display. You won't notice any difference before you power it up. And even after powering it up you should hardly be able to tell a difference between N900 and

Neo900

MINKIN2 2013-08-25 22:30

Re: Neo900 - finally a successor of N900
 
I get that this is still early days, but... Have there been any suggestions as to how the two communities will exist? Could there be any merges or will both teams remain as they are?

lexik 2013-08-25 22:32

Re: Neo900 - finally a successor of N900
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by lonk (Post 1369359)
would it also use a resistive touchscreen like the n900?

It will be "just" GTA04 board in Nokia N900 case - including the screen. Screen, case, keyboard, all these "outfit" things will be still the same.

The change will be the HW. (The PCB)

joerg_rw 2013-08-25 22:34

Re: Neo900 - finally a successor of N900
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by MINKIN2 (Post 1369361)
I get that this is still early days, but... Have there been any suggestions as to how the two communities will exist? Could there be any merges or will both teams remain as they are?

What kind of merging are you thinking of? Tearing down one wiki and integrate it into the other one? Redirect #openmoko-cdevel IRC channel to #maemo channel?
I don't think we need any merge. Just community members will change their habits a bit, regarding their favourite places to lurk and/or contribute. ;-)

/j

Patola 2013-08-25 22:54

Re: Neo900 - finally a successor of N900
 
Will I be able to use my old N900 case with it? I still have mine, although it won't boot anymore.

dos1 2013-08-25 23:00

Re: Neo900 - finally a successor of N900
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Patola (Post 1369367)
Will I be able to use my old N900 case with it? I still have mine, although it won't boot anymore.

Yes! Probably you will be even able to buy just a board and also use the screen from your original N900 :) (and maybe camera?)

joerg_rw 2013-08-25 23:01

Re: Neo900 - finally a successor of N900
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Patola (Post 1369367)
Will I be able to use my old N900 case with it? I still have mine, although it won't boot anymore.

In theory yes. In practice it's completely undecided yet how the marketing will work.

joerg_rw 2013-08-25 23:06

Re: Neo900 - finally a successor of N900
 
[2013-08-26 01:01:36] <freemangordon> anyway, time to have some sleep. Count me in, when it comes to porting the kernel/Fremantle. night

MrZoidberg 2013-08-25 23:12

Re: Neo900 - finally a successor of N900
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by dos1 (Post 1369368)
Yes! Probably you will be even able to buy just a board and also use the screen from your original N900 :) (and maybe camera?)

The camera from Carl Zeiss?^^

Is there already a date for the order?

king Ralphred 2013-08-25 23:14

Re: Neo900 - finally a successor of N900
 
Far more exciting than jolla or ubuntu. Estel can make a sexy body for it.

MINKIN2 2013-08-25 23:16

Re: Neo900 - finally a successor of N900
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by joerg_rw (Post 1369364)
What kind of merging are you thinking of? Tearing down one wiki and integrate it into the other one? Redirect #openmoko-cdevel IRC channel to #maemo channel?
I don't think we need any merge. Just community members will change their habits a bit, regarding their favourite places to lurk and/or contribute. ;-)

/j

Maybe you are right, there might not be a need to merge as such. It is too soon to ask any questions of the sort I will admit (sorry), until the day that there is a substantial user base with the new maemo on the neo900 this may not be an issue that can't be resolved by changing lurking habits. :)

Jordi 2013-08-25 23:44

Re: Neo900 - finally a successor of N900
 
Wow!! Am I dreaming? I hope I will find again this thread tomorrow when I wake up ;)

byteninja2 2013-08-26 00:40

Re: Neo900 - finally a successor of N900
 
You guys really need a kickstarter campain. Make it look really nice (look at the Ubuntu Edge indiegogo campaign) and market it across linux forums, openmoko (what are the openmoko forums?) And this forum, and you could easily get a large amount in Kickstarter. $30,000 maybe?

On another note, where can you buy Openmoko parts? The phone, the GTA04 board, etc.?

joerg_rw 2013-08-26 00:51

Re: Neo900 - finally a successor of N900
 
when I got it right from Nikolaus, we need minimum 200 preorders to start. We might go via kickstarter, or just use the existing wishlist/preorder machine on gta04.org

Lithdk 2013-08-26 00:52

Re: Neo900 - finally a successor of N900
 
I agree on the kickstarter, but they probably arent exactly there yet. However, when they do hit kickstarter level I think they should aim much higher than 30'000. 100K maybe. Get some mass-production going and lower the cost. From my experience and observations, aside from the whole open-source philosophy and life-style, linux users are cheap. So getting the phone made as cheap as realistically possible should be a goal.

dos1 2013-08-26 01:05

Re: Neo900 - finally a successor of N900
 
All we need at this moment is commitment and interest. Only this way Golden Delicious will take their time to actually start the whole thing. Fund rising will come later, if at all (initial batches can be around 200-500 units, then we'll see if it's really worth doing more - I think we can reach 200 without Kickstarter. It may be hard, but still possible). For such batches there's even no need for preordering - as long as Dr. H. Nikolaus Schaller (the man behind GTA04 project) is sure that those 200-500 buyers aren't kidding :P He can invest, it's not "we'll take your money and then start trying to deliver" kind of project (but of course preordering is welcomed, as that's the best insurance for someone's commitment ;))

Personally I do believe it will be worth it :) This project has big potential. Possibly even beyond current active members of Maemo and Openmoko communities.

joerg_rw 2013-08-26 01:11

Re: Neo900 - finally a successor of N900
 
There's only so much we can do about "cheap". The expenses for sourcing the Bill Of Materials is strictly depending on the volume you order. The fixed expense per production run (for prototypes, cert, for setting up and adjusting the fab line etc) is also not anything we can substantially juggle with. Also see dos1's first post in this thread. The list of prices per board versus number of items built, it applies for Neo900 as well as for GTA04, maybe it's even 100 bucks higher for Neo900. The more of you preorder, the cheaper it gets. So it's up to you how much the device will cost in the end ;-D

byteninja2 2013-08-26 01:47

Re: Neo900 - finally a successor of N900
 
Whats Nikoulaus? And, how much will the boards cost? A peice, I am sure they will be a fair bit cheaper in bulk. And, where are you getting N900 cases?

joerg_rw 2013-08-26 03:16

Re: Neo900 - finally a successor of N900
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by byteninja2 (Post 1369386)
Whats Nikoulaus? And, how much will the boards cost? A peice, I am sure they will be a fair bit cheaper in bulk. And, where are you getting N900 cases?

Dr H. Nikolaus Schaller, chief of Golden Delicious Co.
We don't know yet exact prices, see post#5 of Dos1
Cases are available on ebay for example.
/j

glabifrons 2013-08-26 03:35

Re: Neo900 - finally a successor of N900
 
I was extremely excited when I read the title.

I was really hoping for a larger screen though, as my aging eyes can barely focus on the itsy-bitsy N900 screen (I always thought and still think my 770 & N800 pixel-density is perfect).

If the Neo900 has at least 1GB of RAM and at least 2x the CPU, I'd probably still jump on it for ~$300.

If instead it took a different route and had a larger screen (not necessarily higher resolution), I'd probably pay a fair amount more.

Has anyone considered doing this with an N810 body?
After all, if you're swapping out the electronics, you can add in N900 features into its predecessor's case. :D

joerg_rw 2013-08-26 03:45

Re: Neo900 - finally a successor of N900
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by glabifrons (Post 1369394)
Has anyone considered doing this with an N810 body?
After all, if you're swapping out the electronics, you can add in N900 features into its predecessor's case. :D


Yes, but it is really hard to find N810, and almost impossible to find cases. And the N810 case has way more metal than N900 and thus it becomes really difficult to implement a decent RF/antennae-design.
You might find an option to order a custom Neo900 though, eventually. With your own custom made case and a larger screen.
See https://shop.goldelico.com/wiki.php?page=GTA04%20Custom for an example with GTA04.

RobbieThe1st 2013-08-26 03:56

Re: Neo900 - finally a successor of N900
 
Hm, if this can be done for a reasonable price, I'd be interested... in a replacement board. I've already got two 'broken' devices, so all I'd want is a board.

Heck, I'd be happy with a N900 board re-soldered with a better eMMC and more ram - CPU can be overvolted and OC'd up to 1GHZ well enough for me(It's been two years or so; I'm happy).

That being said, if you're going to the trouble of re-designing the board and doing a lot of work that way, I'd much prefer a /much/ faster CPU (OMAP 4?), and would pay more for it.

joerg_rw 2013-08-26 04:06

Re: Neo900 - finally a successor of N900
 
it's hard to source OMAP4 afaik. also the design of GTA04 has a DM3730 SoC and we don't plan to do a complete new development, we just reshape the PCB and maybe do minor changes to some periperal chips to better meet the N900 specs for fremantle's sake.

byteninja2 2013-08-26 04:32

Re: Neo900 - finally a successor of N900
 
Wow, I checked out the site, surly a GTA0s board won't cost 500 pounds?! And, I was looking at ebay, N900 cases can be bought for less then $20 from China. I think software will be the part that requires the most time. Maybe you should raise enough money to buy 100 boards and cases and to hire a couple devs. I think $300 is the most most people will spend, so try to keep it around there.

joerg_rw 2013-08-26 04:37

Re: Neo900 - finally a successor of N900
 
http://talk.maemo.org/showpost.php?p...2&postcount=30
300EUR is hardly reachable. We'll most likely end with a price between 600EUR and 800EUR. For 300 we need to build and sell 100k devices. Please keep in mind that iirc the N900 initially also was 599EUR and Nokia for sure built more than 200 devices and has better stand to negotiate prices with chip manufs anyway. Actually I'm afraid that Nikolaus calculates too low and in the end will have a loss on the whole enterprise and thus discontinue the whole thing.

byteninja2 2013-08-26 04:58

Re: Neo900 - finally a successor of N900
 
Yes, I forgot about that. I think 650 dollars is good, but I sure hope they don't ask to little then kill it.

joerg_rw 2013-08-26 05:18

Re: Neo900 - finally a successor of N900
 
added poll for upper limit every interested community member was able to pay, Keep in mind that we need to reach a certain number of preorders to even start production. My absolute ballpark guess not backed up by any in-detail evaluation is that we will reach 700EUR with a number of 200 preorders. Please vote honest! In the unlikely case that one vote doesn't suffice for you since you'd need a dozen devices, please state in thread post


All times are GMT. The time now is 23:27.

vBulletin® Version 3.8.8